Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Albert Schindler's avatar

As usual at very thought-provoking article. Thank you. Your article reminds me of the Biblical life-lesson where Jesus joins his disciple in a boat and calms a storm may sea (Matthew 8:23-27).

I'll use a paragraph that I cliped from EVS Bible Study to better explain my thought.

... And when he [the Great Teacher} got into the boat [this world], his disciples followed him. And behold, there arose a great storm on the sea [the world was becoming a dangerous and scary place to be in], so that the boat [life on earth] was being swamped by the waves; but he [the Master Teacher/Wise One] was asleep [to the scary happenings in the world]. And they [the frightened, worried common people of the world] went and woke him [brought the wise one's attention to what was happening in the world], saying, “Save us, Lord; we are perishing.” And [the teacher] said to them, “Why are you afraid, o you of little faith?” Then he rose and rebuked the winds and the sea [taught the residents the true, ancient knowledge of the Gods], and there was a great calm. And the men [those who heeded the words of the Wise Teacher] marveled, saying, “What sort of man is this, that even winds and sea obey him?”

Expand full comment
Ananda X. Suddath's avatar

Indeed, all the changes, crises and collapses we’re witnessing are happening against a cultural backdrop where scientific materialism has successfully imposed itself as the dominant religious discourse for modern times. (This isn’t true everywhere, but it’s very much the case in progressive cities. I live in Montreal, a global hub AI; my comment speaks to the view from here.)

We’ve gone from a society where it’s taboo to be a non-believer to one where it’s taboo to put one’s faith in something that “is impossible to measure or quantify, and therefore can’t be proven to exist.” We’re under intense cultural pressure to dispense with our proverbial right brains which, for all intents and purposes, are where God, the Universe, the Big Beat, e.g., would usually “go” to be actively, holistically and regularly engaged with.

This technocratic pressure to dismiss “magical thinking” and “irrational beliefs” is exerted via subtle and less-subtle forms of socially-sanctioned shaming, and achieves its aims once we cave to the pressure and admit that we, too, believe that anything beyond the small fragments reality we can realistically deal with as tiny sentient beings can only be a compensatory figment of humanity’s imagination.

I see the pendulum swinging back in people I know to be exhausted from the last 4 years in particular. They’re finding Jesus for the first time, or going home to the various belief systems they were raised with. They’re finding solace and liberation through ritual, community, and clear and functional strategies for achieving states of peace, trust, and surrender. This doesn’t strike me as being totally risk-free (cults, e.g.), and it’s not something I personally gravitate towards. However, I do understand (and experience) the need for religious experience and, to the degree that a person hasn’t signed up for something toxic or become a sanctimonious jerk, I’m happy if they’re happy.

I can only infer that a culture that cuts us off from the Divine, broadly speaking, is one hell-bent on keeping us small, scared, atomized, and consuming from the (dis)comfort of our treadmills.



This can’t be all there is.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts